MEL CHURCHER on The Differences Between Stage and Screen Acting

MEL CHURCHER on The Differences Between Stage and Screen Acting

Today, I’m delighted to introduce another guest blog, from someone that has inspired me in my progress as an acting coach over the years and I hope she inspires you too, Mel Churcher. Mel has been an acting and voice coach for many years and worked on such films as The Fifth Element, Lara Croft and Chalet Girl, Sherlock Holmes and Unleashed. Two of her books are on my recommended reading list in my Amazon AStore, please have a look at them after this and perhaps you’ll be persuaded to get your hands on them after you’ve read her blog.  We may differ on some specific issues of technique, but I’m sure like me, you can learn a lot from her.

Screen acting and theatre acting have differences. Here are my big three:

The first and most important is often the last one that actors think about and yet the most crucial: In theatre, there is an audience. In film, at the moment of acting, there is no audience. Sounds obvious. Yet understanding this will have a deep, subtle effect on your work. On stage, you always share with people out there in the darkness. There is interplay between you and the audience – the observers and the observed. When filming, you are surrounded by technicians, but they are not your audience. Only a few key people like the director, the producer, script supervisor and sound crew are even wearing headphones to hear what you are saying! The camera, certainly, isn’t your audience. It’s a recording device that will document your acting life. (Which will be cut and pasted at your director’s discretion and shown on a screen much later if you are lucky.) You must open yourself up to it, to be minutely scrutinised by it, but you “share” with it at your peril. Once you help us to understand your subtext or the story, you will seem false. You have to find your “real” life and surroundings within this weird world full of cameras, microphones and people – to be a child again and believe, in the moment of acting, that there is no one else there but the other roles inhabiting this “reality” with you. You need to think hard at every moment and drive what you (in the role) need. But not add anything else. The camera will see your thoughts. Thinking (without “showing”) is enough and you have to trust it. You mustn’t add “sub-titles”. All you can do is “be in the moment” of acting. We will see genuine emotion. Your eyes literally shine with all the thoughts that light them up. Too often, this light dims when an actor is speaking learnt text. All the thoughts, memories and pictures in your head need to be as specific and extra-ordinary as they are in life. You need life and humour in your eyes. You must be as multi-dimensional and interesting as real complex human beings are – as you are!

Next – film is shot out of order. You may bury your lover before you've met them or murder your boss before the interview. Each scene is done from many different angles (or set-ups). The bigger the production, the more set-ups there will be. Each set-up can involve many takes and each take needs to be fresh and spontaneous. So film takes tremendous imagination and focus, not to mention, stamina.

Which brings me rehearsal. Or rather the lack of it. There's not much rehearsal for film well, not as we know it in theatre. And, until you arrive on set for shooting, you may never have rehearsed with, or even met, the actors with whom you are going to play the scene. You need to do a tremendous amount of preparation before you get to that set. But it must be the right kind. It is you as if you were in that situation or living in that time. And that as if could mean a complete change of physicality, depending on the life you've led in the role. You might be a medieval peasant or an astronaut. Who am I and Where am I? must take the life you've led and the period into account. And you have to reach it organically through research, physical work and specific imagination. At a deep level, you have to, truly, inhabit that imagined world. What do I want in the role? Your needs must be powerful and strong. These needs may be hidden to the other characters (that's sub-text), but strong needs must drive you. Beware of deciding how you get what you want or how you say the lines. If you plot a course or decide how to play the scene, you will not be open to react in the moment. Turn off the director in your head. You don't know what the others will bring yet. You need to stay open to all possibilities. When you were a child, you didn't say, Now, I'm going to show you a character called Superman, who can fly. You said,˜I'm Superman! I can fly and you must think like that with your roles.

Mel Churcher

Mel has recently started writing a blog and you can find it here.

free pdf

The 12 Obstacles

written by mark westbrook

One of the biggest obstacles to a successful acting career is the inner critic, the voice in your head, but there are many more.

In this free advice guide, Acting Coach and Performance Psychology expert Mark Westbrook outlines the most common inner obstacles to success and offers you insightful and practical tools for overcoming them.

Download Your Free Copy

fancy a chat?

We want to hear from you. If you have questions or queries, our Admin Team would love to answer them for you. Our office hours are typically Monday-Thursday, 3:30-9:30pm and 10am-2pm on Saturdays. Get in touch today. 

Check our Privacy Policy for how and how long we use your information. We guarantee that we will never sell your data to a third party. 

  • +44 (0)141 440 1272

General Message